Review of EU Companies’ Climate Plans: Insights from Reporting
As part of EUKI’s project “Company Climate Transition”, Frank Bold has published its research on corporate sustainability disclosures based on the assessment of 100 reports from large EU companies and banks disclosing under the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD). The study includes 55 companies from Central and Eastern Europe (CEE) and 45 from Western Europe, reviewing the information disclosed on climate targets, transition plans, climate risk assessment and greenhouse gas accounting, as well as double materiality, due diligence, biodiversity and governance.
The assessment of how companies are presenting their climate targets and transition plans provides critical evidence on the readiness of the corporate sector for sustainable finance, clean industrial policies and green public procurement rules. The CSRD is meant to help channel capital towards sustainable investment and manage climate-related financial risks, while the EU’s industrial competitiveness depends on companies actually transforming their business.
The research shows progress in the quality of disclosures and transparency in general, but also that climate ambition has stalled and that the transition is hesitant. Without credible transition plans, investors, regulators and public buyers have little basis to reward frontrunners. Moreover, a corporate sector that is unprepared for the transition poses a structural risk for EU competitiveness, energy security and strategic autonomy.
Here is what our research reveals about companies’ reporting on climate:
Decarbonisation targets
85 companies now disclose decarbonisation targets, up from 73 last year, and nearly all specify a timeframe. Ambition, however, has stalled: net-zero commitments were made by 41 companies and carbon-neutrality commitments backed by reduction targets by 10, both nearly unchanged from last year. Of the 85 companies that have adopted targets, 56 set interim targets or pathways. This suggests that targets from the remaining companies are either short-term in nature or not yet substantiated with a credible pathway. It is also relevant to monitor whether net-zero and climate-neutrality claims may decline next year as the Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition (EmpCo) limits generic claims that lack a verifiable implementation plan.
Transition plans
68 companies now report on their climate transition plans, up from 54 last year, and disclosure of investment strategies nearly doubled, from 22 to 45 companies. Still, many plans are incomplete or only labelled as such: they set a long-term goal and short-term actions without a mid-term perspective. About 15 % of companies that declare a plan fail to show its basic elements, a share virtually unchanged from last year. Only around 20 companies explain how their plan aligns with a 1.5°C pathway.
18 use entity-specific metrics to track progress. While this figure seems low, it has risen sharply and represents a strong indicator of good practice.
As observed last year, companies in the CEE region continue to lag behind in terms of completeness of information on their climate transition plans, with 95% of Western companies (43 out of 45) presenting basic CTP elements compared with 45% in the CEE (25 out of 55).
Financial sector
Overall, from the 17 financial institutions in the sample, only 5 disclose decarbonisation targets with interim milestones, and 7 provide robust sector financing policies specifying concrete levers or targets for decarbonisation.
Our research sample included more financial institutions from the CEE (13), in comparison with Western Europe (4). The drop in quality is more pronounced among CEE financial institutions, where 10 had decarbonisation targets but only 4 had tailored decarbonisation plans for high-impact sectors. All Western European financial institutions had decarbonisation targets, and 3 had sector-tailored decarbonisation plans.
This is problematic as disclosure of a target without accompanying sector-level policies (criteria, levers, timelines for energy, manufacturing and similar sectors) tells little about what the financial institution will actually do. The sectors where CEE companies need to decarbonise most depend on bank finance, and if local banks’ lending practice do not embed robust transition strategy focused on transition pathways in critical sectors, CEE companies lack incentives to plan major investments, and those who do anyway may find it harder to get transition finance. The same banks may also carry more climate-related financial risk, for example in asset quality and collateral values, which is relevant for the prudential treatment of climate risk at EU level.
Conclusions and recommendations
The EU CSRD and EU Sustainability Reporting Standards provide a robust disclosure framework on transition, climate risk and emissions. They have ensured a high level of transparency, making it much easier than before to differentiate between unsubstantiated claims and credible transition plans.
However, to actually embed transition in their strategy, companies and financial institutions must treat transition planning as a matter of competitive resilience, not compliance. They should close the gap between targets and credible pathways, with interim milestones, investment plans and measurable progress. Where there is no plan yet, they should say so rather than label something a plan. Critically, financial institutions in the CEE region should develop sector-specific expectations and objectives for high-impact sectors.
Regulators and auditors need to play their part and challenge transition plans that are not credible, and EU policymakers should reward front-runners through access to capital and public procurement.
Explore in more detail our research and other related work of the project: